Alain de Botton tackles religion in the same manner that Alan Partridge extols the virtues of the Travel Tavern and its breakfast buffet. Namely, by filling his oversized plate with the best bits while trying to convince us the concept isn’t the last refuge for the lost and lonely, but a functional necessity for modern-day life.
De Botton is a committed atheist but here, and in his book Religion For Atheists, he was determined to move on the debate from “sterile” arguments of whether there is a God, to look at how parts of religion could improve the lives of all.
He told us that secular society could benefit from the belief in life-long learning that is prevalent in many religions, as opposed to being a mere buzzword among politicians and educationalists.
Similarly, we could learn from religious art which, no matter how intricate the work, the simple messages within them stir the soul and can be understood by a child.
Religion, he added, also fosters supportive communities and has a far better grasp of architecture, as opposed to viewing land as a business transaction.
Unfortunately for de Botton, he failed to show how we could apply the best of religion to practical life. He also sidestepped the facts, for example, that the great religious masterpieces and the building of opulent cathedrals usually stemmed from blind faith and obedience.
Likewise, as some churchgoers will concede, the quiet congregations are often not supportive communities but actually riddled with divisions, with only faith uniting them.
He failed to realise that if you take faith away, his religious breakfast buffet is left with little more than granola. Secular society, on the other hand, has been adequately filling the void with an almighty full English for years.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here